Thursday, February 20, 2014

Going With the Flow

I am always surprised at how much music depends on sounds that cannot be written down, i.e., on resonance, which you might say is the subject of Tonal Refraction.

This element is often disregarded in training children, though it is arguably the dimension of sound that most intrigues them: just tap on a tiny bell or other reverberant object and see the infant's eyes light up.

This aspect of Chopin's music, properly brought to life, makes an indelible impression.  I will never forget hearing for the first time Rubinstein in Carnegie Hall stopping time with the opening sound of the D-flat Major Nocturne.  It stays with me as the model of how the piano works, and of how music written for the piano works.

Once having learned to ignore this element it is wondrously difficult to bring it to the fore.  To do this I recommend playing pianissimo with half-pedal, never changing the pedal through mistakes and all.  As you feel the vibrations accumulate they begin to make a kind of sense that analyzable harmonies simply cannot achieve.

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Early Does Not Mean Simplistic

Last night I attended a concert by an early music group made up primarily of players of viols with some individual solo parts, violin and vocalists.

First, addressing pitch:  There are a limited number of pitches in this music.  Is that really true?  Not if the vocalism that clearly prompts them is taken into account, in which case one would be struck over and over again by the dynamic range possible when the direction of approach is taken into account.  The violinist understood this and played so that it came alive in pitch.  The accompanying viols were careful, did not pick up the ball much less return it.  Result: droning.

Second, concerning rhythm(s): The bowing technique of period instrument invites rapid response, more like flickering than changes of bow direction.  This puts some attacks on the early, some on the late side side of the beat.  Again, the violinist stood out while the others seemed to be hiding behind correctness.

I don't go to concerts to hear correctness.  I want the players' listening to raise my listening to a new level. 

Tonal Refraction and the Limitations of Standard Music Notation

I have been reworking a Tonal Refraction of Schumann's Waldszenen, the subject of Vol. II of my series on Tone Perception Visualized.

It is a cycle of nine puzzles, some more puzzling than others.  The one currently foremost in my imagination is called Einsame Blumen and is marked to be played Einfach.  (Isolated Blossoms ?  to be played simply?)

I observe certain rules in making a Tonal Refraction: The tones under a slur rise if the last note under the slur is higher than the first, fall if the last tone is lower, and do not assert direction if the two notes are the same.  What a revelation this is when playing the work!

As a child I was taught that musical phrases go somewhere.  Here only some of them do.  Are those the isolated blossoms to which the title refers?  If so, the phrases that do not move are only increasing that quality of isolation.  What about the left hand articulations:  staccato eighth notes function very differently from sustained half notes under those right hand groupings.  Maybe simply observing these articulations is, in fact, the"simply" Schumann had in mind.

All I can say is that it is bloody difficult to do it.

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Late Schumann, Again

Thinking about the intimate aspects of late Schumann recalls the intimate aspects of early counterpoint, the historical moment when a second voice was added to the plainsong.  The most intimate connection between the two voices occurs only when they share the same vowel on either a unison, a fifth, or an octave.  Then it is as if the single voices merge into one voice.

Poor musicians, not enjoying this disappearance, will deliberately play out of tune so that everyone knows they are still "there."  (I used to play with such a violinist.)

In the Op. 132 Schumann deals with the very unlike timbres of clarinet and viola by daring them, as it were, to merge within overtones, sympathetically reinforced or melded together by the piano.  But, given the instrumentation, these overtones are not the run of the mill string overtones.  They require some seeking after by all parties.  Clarinets do not resonate in the same way as violas.  Pianos can go with the flow -- can, in fact, direct the flow by not interfering with it.

None of this can be written down in standard notation.   This leads me straight into the next blogpost on Tonal Refraction.

Monday, February 17, 2014

Late Schumann in the Hands of Fine Musicians: Fairy Tales, Op 132

Last night I went to hear a trio of fine musicians play late Schumann: Maerchenerzaehlungen, Op. 132, for clarinet, viola and piano.  It is one of those borderline comprehensible works that tempt Philistines to attribute to the composer's madness.

One thing particularly struck me:  In the third piece the players are asked to produce two startling, sometimes ugly sounds of equal intensity, one after the other -- effectively two downbeats in a row.  It happens again and again in the piece, each time interspersed with scampering sounds evoking the image of little children running away from the menacing ogre.  How apt.

It is, indeed, menacing to produce two equally strong sounds one right after the other.  Well-behaved musicians do not do things like that.  It took me a while to figure it out, myself.

What is a fairy tale, after all, but an excursion into a fantasy world where logic does not prevail, where control is abandoned temporarily in favor of excess?  Schumann writes all kinds of excess into these pieces, including excess of intimacy.

I would have to say that these musicians did get it some of the time, but only as if by accident.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

"Lonely Blossoms"

Einsame Blume is the title of the second piece in Schumann's Waldszenen.  What might this title mean, as I am convinced he is not evoking pretty pictures but rather describing his compositional goal.

Making a Tonal Refraction of the piece clarifies it to an astonishing degree.  The "melody" is, for the most part, changing without going anywhere.  It moves neither up nor down, it embellishes vibrations briefly defined by disconnected harmonies, often skeletal, in the left hand.

This is a staggering effect, since it defies all the laws of projection-at-all-costs that characterize so much of a pianist's training.

Try moving without going anywhere.   It attains a level of intimacy that is almost undescribable.

Saturday, February 15, 2014

Square is Square

Explaining to a non-musician what it means to play beats I compared it to a fixation with right angles: everything has to line up nice and tidy with an identifiable beat.

If I hear more than, say, three of such beats in a row I am almost certainly going to lose interest.  All kinds of things can occur to enliven beats: little things like unpredictable accentuation, or no accentuation at all; and bigger things like groupings of three within a 4/4 meter.

I am appalled at the amount of square playing I hear when I tune into the classical music station at random.  How thrilling, on the other hand, to hear something that is the opposite of square.

Two performances I heard yesterday qualify for that:  Stephen Hough playing the Grieg Piano Concerto, which squares maintain is an uninteresting piece - boy are they missing something!
Gustav Dudamel conducting those famous Dances from Borodin's Prince Igor, in a live performance with the Berlin Philharmonic.