Thursday, March 18, 2010

The difference between white key and black key sonority on the piano is striking to a child. It is perhaps one of the reasons why children balk at reading music in the flat keys. I decided to test that proposition the other day by having a child read and react to, one sound at a time, a Haydn minuet in E-flat.

Her responses to the specific voicing of intervals, position of black in relation to white keys, registral placement on the piano -- all revealed extremely vivid ear-pure response.

I asked her if the sounds bothered her when she heard me play. "No," she replied, "because you know what is coming next."

Incidentally, the strategy was to begin not at the beginning but at a cadence. Reading "backward" from the cadence -- i.e., approaching it from increasing distances -- clarified a context in which all kinds of dissonance became meaningful. She ended up playing the whole thing at first sitting, by her choice, though it was not at all a simple piece.

I take this as a clear demonstration of why I do not teach major keys as if they are interchangeable: they are not!

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

It is one thing to protest against a tyrannical political situation. How does one protest meaningfully against an accepted canon of knowledge which does not correspond to perceived experience?

Traditionally one takes one's case to painting, to tone, to something--anything--non-verbal or if verbal, poetic or fictional.

The evidence for such protest is, of course, anecdotal. But one has to examine the source: what is the level of experience behind the protest? Doesn't that carry some weight? Or do we have to wait 150 years to recognize the validity of the finding?

A book that treats this phenomenon bears the unlikely title "Proust was a Neuro-Scientist." Though I disagree with some of its presentations, the point is well-taken. Those who demand proof are often 150 years behind those who detected the phenomenon by experience and found a way to convey their experience, though it went unrecognized for the intervening 150 years.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Even a casual reader of The New York Times cannot help but notice that hardly a day goes by when the results of some study or another are cited as convincing proof that .... Reading carefully one runs across the word "anecdotal" in contrast to these scientifically controlled tests.

Then there are the obituaries. In today's paper is the compelling story of Arnall Patz, a doctor who observed a possible link between the high levels of oxygen delivered to premature babies and blindness, and who took it upon himself (together with a pediatrician colleague) to test the possible connection "[d]espite a lack of training in research and grant support."

The obit goes on: "At the age of 78 he went back... to earn a master of liberal arts degree....In one term paper he explored how Beethoven's progressive deafness affected his music."

Clearly an observant man, interested in exceptions to the rule and unafraid to be himself an exception.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Yesterday I heard a beautiful presentation on the subject of stained glass window restoration in which process the windows are photographed both from the outside and from the inside. I thought how like music that is.

Most of our culture defines music as seen from the outside; a better working definition would surely be from the inside.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

If you asked me to define music I wouldn't know where to start. But I notice that there a kind of barrier implied in the word. People either consider themselves insiders or outsiders. Over and over again I hear people say they cannot sing or that they can no longer sing, or something like that. They defer to those who have developed skills in music.

As much as I always wanted to feel real competence as a musician I was not willing to give up that other aspect of music, which is the sheer fun of making a joyful noise together with others. It gets people all confused: how can one have it both ways?

The answer sounds simple but is not really simple at all: By listening for the intent behind the effort. Skill is not very interesting all by itself. It is not easy to listen that way. I compare it to going for a walk with either a very young or a very old person: you must forget for the moment that you know how to walk.

Saturday, March 13, 2010

Beginning next week I will present a series of three informal afternoons at the piano, in what will be more performance art events than recitals. The idea is to stimulate audience awareness of the piano as a young peoples' invention -- which it would have been had it been invented after, rather than before the Industrial Revolution.

The focus of these events will be the ear, as it always should be in a performance of music, but all too often isn't. The ear is fast--really fast. But because we live in a culture of too much sound, a lot of our ear-energy is spent tuning out rather than tuning in. Being tuned in means being rapt in the aura of sound that makes every one as magic as the tinkling of a bell or of the triangle in the orchestra.

If you are interested in more information please get in touch via email: nancygarniez@tonalrefraction.com. It would be great to see you there.

Friday, March 12, 2010

What it all comes down to is that listening is an activity but an extremely complex activity: difficult to observe, difficult to cultivate, difficult to articulate.

I read descriptions of aural skills required at various levels in music schools and I am puzzled. To what extent are these truly aural skills and to what extent are they verbalization skills? These are two rather different things.

My young improvising student has remarkable aural skills that he cannot verbalize. But why should he have to? I cannot imagine that the verbalization would enhance the sensitivity of his listening since it entails an intellectual bypass, which involves slowing down the auditory response.

If I compare his listening to my own I notice that my listening to notated music (Beethoven sonatas, for example) is filtered by a visual/verbal process that identifies the sound before I hear it. I cannot imagine that that corresponds to Beethoven's mode of hearing. If anything, the notation of conventional harmony is but a portal to a richer, fuller auditory experience made distinctive by the precise placement of black keys in relation to white, low pitches in relation to high, and so on. It has taken me years to catch on.