Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Frederico Busoni, Another Great Teacher

The second memorable phrase that has inspired me for many years I found in Great Pianists on Piano Playing, a compendium of essays by prominent pianists of the day (1917), now reprinted by Dover.    Frederico Busoni wrote: "All technical exercises must be given to the pupil with great discretion and judgment just as poisonous medicines must be administered to the patient with great care."

What respect for the hand, for the ear, for the student's imagination!

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Schnabel the Teacher


Artur Schnabel once famously said: "First hear, then play."   Figuring out what he might have meant has taken me quite a while, not only in terms of my own playing but also exploring whether it is possible to train children to give priority to listening.

One of the critical aspects of this admonition is its implication that passive hearing is irrelevant.  In a way it implies a rewording: Hearing is more important than playing. 

If you agree you certainly would not dream of going through the motions of playing, doing the kind of exercises some pianists (the late Charles Rosen, among others) boast they practice while reading novels.

When I listen to anyone play I figure out first of all whether they are listening first.  If they aren't, I leave, regardless of the ticket price.





Monday, March 4, 2013

Listening as an Animal Listens for Danger

The Deagan Chime Company was located just a few blocks away from my childhood home on Paulina St. in Chicago.  That the chimes ringing every quarter-hour had anything to do with telling time was beyond me as a small child.  I was fascinated by that four-part melody: Why did it stop there?  was my question.  When was it going to come back?

I believe this atmospheric involvement with a much-loved sound was the model for my life of listening for meaning.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Practicing is Overrated

I was amused to read in a footnote to a chapter on the art and teaching of Artur Schnabel that a colleague of mine chastised Schnabel in no uncertain terms (in print, not face to face) for recommending that piano students not practice so much.  Schnabel maintained that he did most of his preparation while going for walks.

I tell my young students not to practice and, if they do, to tell somebody else.  Of course, I can tell right away that they have or haven't practiced.  What is more important than practicing is dreaming about music, any music.  Internalizing is really difficult.  Getting the external music to match the internal is the work of a lifetime -- work worthy of a lifetime.   Putting the emphasis on the external aspects (i.e., technique), especially at an early age, merely  fogs the issue.




Saturday, March 2, 2013

Boredom / Frustration

In a recent radio interview British psychoanalyst Adam Phillips was discussing the importance of frustration: acknowledging it, accepting it, dealing with it as important determinants of a fulfilled self.

He might have been speaking of boredom in practicing music.  Some of the most fulfilling aspects of my musicianship have emerged from my acknowledgement of utter boredom, with the Alberti bass, for example, which has become one of the features of Classical style that I most enjoy.

Friday, March 1, 2013

Orchestration and Bartok's Roumanian Dances

Apparently Bartok himself orchestrated the Roumanian Dances about which I was complaining recently.
Curious to explore the issue further, I checked on Wikipedia where there is a link to a recording of three of the dances by the Adelphi Chamber Orchestra (unknown to me).  Listening to their sound I realized that they don't sound like any ensemble I have ever heard, nor would they probably be given the time of day were they to audition for a gig in NY in 2013.  They are clearly playing with sounds in mind with which we are totally unfamiliar, and with a kind of manic energy that simply does not get conveyed in printed music.

So the orchestration is inseparable from the orchestra doing the playing.  Had that been the version to which I was initially exposed things might have been altogether different.  Who knows?

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Memory of Things Unheard

Among the strongest influences in my creative life have been two friends, one a visual artist, the other a poet.  In conversation the other day the novelist Jose Saramago's description of the real subject matter of painting came up, specifically that every good painting depicts something unseen.  The question arose whether there is a comparable level of content in music.

I maintain that it is memory: Every musical sound refers to some remembered sound, whether "the same" or not.  Perhaps it is to remind us of this simple truth that so much European music contains quotes from nature and from other sources (I refer to European music because it is the music I know best, not to exclude every other music).

It is a real loss that, in the name of music, so many young children are being force-fed tunes and notes as if that constitutes the blood and breath of the real thing.