Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Saving Time by Taking Time

What do we have if not time?  Musicians live and breathe time in many guises, constantly.  Thinking about my immersion in the Brahms Horn Trio with natural horn and violin I am stunned at the stop-time aspect of having to listen to and account for every single tone, not just of this theme or that.

Every time the horn changes pitch it is as if a different word were being inflected by the most insightful singer.  Having worked a lot with singers I know what that entails: nothing short of constant, open-minded attentiveness.

By taking the time to work at this level we give one another a gift of timelessness.

So what's the rush?

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

K1 P1

What does knitting reveal about music?

Just as composition has a great deal to do with mathematical proportions and with variations within and upon patterns, so does knitting.  At the moment I am working on a String Improvisation for which I decided to use a multiple of 4 stitches as the basic design unit.

After a very short time I realized why Beethoven prefers the plus one, minus one principle:  3 + 5 is so much more interesting!  Even numbers quickly cloy.  (Sounds like the text to one of those Elizabethan lute songs, or at least a Gilbert & Sullivan parody of same.)

So why do we still teach children rhythm in even numbers?  When you figure that one out please let me know.

Monday, June 30, 2014

Falling Apart

We did it: three times yesterday.  Three quite serious otherwise capable players fell apart beginning a
composition we had already played together at least once.  After train wrecks about eight bars in we had to start again, and again,and yet again, each time with considerable laughter.

Who is that thumbing his nose at us from heaven?  Brahms.  The piece? His Horn Trio (with natural horn, of course). 

Why did it fall apart?

We simply did as indicated in the score, rather the violinist, Gregor Kitzis did as indicated, observing the slurs and other meticulous articulations.  Doing so lifted the music right off the page and into the realm of pure delight.

Have I ever heard anyone play the piece like that?  Have you?

Sunday, June 29, 2014

Building Responsive Audience

An article in the NYTimes on Tuesday, June 24 cited new guidelines of the Pediatrics Association recommending that people read to their children from birth.  Accompanying the article is a photo which tells it all.  The pediatrician holding the book with a joyful expression on her face, is looking at the nine-month-old.  Holding the infant is her 33-year-old mother looking, as is the infant, at the book, but with a relatively subdued smile on her face.

If would be better for those three individuals and for society in general if the child were looking at her mother's face rather than at the book.  The one sporting the most exuberant expression, the pediatrician, is a non-essential element in the facial exchange.  It is a matter of mother-child connection, of a powerful model for daily interaction.

This can be achieved by singing to infants from day one, as I have advocated many times on this blog.  Not just singing a song, but singing so as to activate every muscle in the face, to arouse every possible feeling that might accompany a raised eyebrow, a mouth opened to a round "O," a sly smile to evoke mischief.  

This has all been studied and documented by Daniel Stern (The Interpersonal World of the Infant) in his studies of the attunement of infants to their parents.  Great word: Attunement.

  • Two things to note: The Broadway-musical-show-biz expression on the doctor's face would probably be what caught the editor's eye as a strong selling point to draw attention to the article.
  • My letter to the Times making the point of this blogpost did not get printed.

Saturday, June 28, 2014

Generic Just Won't Do

My favorite illustration of generic remains the memory of what happened on a Sunday afternoon thirty years ago.  During an afternoon open house.I answered the doorbell to behold two completely unidentifiable young women.  Clearly struck speechless by my inability to recognize them, I was restored to myself when one of them said, "It's okay!  We're generic!"

It was my daughter and a friend who, having just completed an entire day as demonstration subjects for a beauticians' convention, were coiffed and made up to look like everyone else.  Their persons had become completely invisible.

Last night I chanced to hear for the second time on the radio a startling recording of Schubert's Moment Musicaux, No. 1 played by a lyrical Portugese pianist.  I recall my reaction at the first hearing:  This is a sensitive, insightful player, though the reading in no way resembles my own.

I looked her up on the Internet where there are videos of her playing.  I detected what I identify as post-recording (the musical equivalent of post-modern?) piano technique, i.e., playing in which finger legato does not exist, where the action of the dampers is therefore so controlled that sympathetic vibration virtually disappears.  This alters every connection in the piece, from one note to the next, one phrase to the next.  It is finely shaped generic playing made to save time in the recording process: the very kind of result I seek to prove inadequate to the player, the composition, the listener.

Friday, June 27, 2014

Different Intelligences

In a few weeks I will be presenting samples of my visualization work at an International Conference on Music Perception and Cognition in Seoul, Korea.  In preparation I have been showing the work to some acquaintances.

Their reactions make clear to me that the most important example I will show is also perhaps the most innocent: that of an eight-year-old boy depicting the tones of a Bartok melody he was having trouble reading.  It is a graphic depiction not just of the melody, but of his exuberance when at last he "got" it.

Why is it important?  Because, after 17 years the boy is still studying with me.  I describe our work together from time to time on this blog.  He is a professional computer animator.  A visual intelligence.

Though I cannot prove it scientifically, my guess is that having affirmed the validity of visual thinking in relation to music at a very early stage of learning permits us, working together, to find parallels between the inner workings of his mind and Beethoven's compositional process, the current subject of our work together.

Thursday, June 26, 2014

The Inanity of the Alberti Figure

Back to the "Moonlight" Sonata, third movement.  Long stretches of this movement feature the highly repetitive Alberti figure, mostly accompanying a somewhat square melody with obscure expression markings, like hairpin swells and decrescendos. 

Taking a closer listen to these passages proved extremely revealing this morning.  Assuming, as I do, that the function of the Alberti figure is to set off ripples of reverberation from the most often repeated tone, the other tones either reinforce or collide with those reverberations, producing a kaleidoscopic bouncing and rebounding of tones and overtones, making a rhythm that cannot be described or written down.  It can only be experienced and respected as taking on a life of its own, independent of controlled thought or instrumental technique.

The strings are literally doing the work.

It is nothing short of shocking to work through these passages tone by tone to experience the care with which Beethoven made the choices he did about which notes to change in which direction.

I consider this the most difficult challenge of the movement, though at first glance it seems the most obvious, almost inane.