Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Autistic Achievement via Bartok

One of my longtime (16 years) students is blind, autistic, and severely developmentally challenged.  Underneath all those opacities he is a real human being and music is his only access to shared experience and to real expression.  He has long been fascinated by the music of Bartok, specifically For Children.  His many problems are complicated even further by the absence of a sense of touch. From the very beginning my pedagogy with him has been based on two fundamental principles:
  • Variation, variation, more variation.  Never repeat yourself; never play the "same" piece twice the same way.
  • Dissonance, dissonance, more dissonance.  Whatever the problems he has learning, he is bound to grow into some kind of unexpressible awareness of his limitations.  Dissonance is the musical equivalent of what he cannot otherwise express.
Today he enjoyed a spectacular lesson in which he accomplished some coordinations which had, not long ago, been impossible for him: He opened his left hand to play an octave then promptly returned to a closed position for the rest of the figure.  He could combine this new challenge with the melody which is itself deceptively simple - it has asymmetrical phrasing, and is not consonant with the accompaniment in the same way in any of its three verses.  

Why could he make the effort today that he could not begin to imagine several weeks ago?  I think it's because he has grown to love the piece, to such an extent that he is fascinated by its complexities. I know he loves it because it's what he played when I asked him to play anything at all at the start of the lesson.

What a student loves is the key to learning, no matter who the student and who the teacher.

Monday, February 2, 2015

Knowing a Piece Really Well

I know that I know a piece really well when I grasp the importance of its pushes as well as pulls, that is, the places where the note values and the articulations require me to resist forward motion, or indeed, not to move at all.

It was a true compliment when someone noted a couple of weeks ago that the Mozart I played seemed to move backwards.  That is exactly what I wanted to convey.  Of course, one cannot move backwards, but music is full of indications of reluctance: reluctance to move ahead, to rise, to fall, to resolve.

So much of my early Wagnerian-style training was based on a model of onward and upward that it is still hard to proceed confidently in the opposite direction.

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Let's Hear It For Left Hands!

How often the sense of a piano work is contained in the left hand, so often neglected because it does not have the melody.

It took me a while to figure out that the usual division of music into three elements, melody, harmony, and rhythm, was entirely phoney, that a lot of music is a magical combination of the three so that they are in fact inseparable.

Having been trained as an organist I spent a lot of time identifying and articulating fugue subjects and counter-subjects.  One day I woke up to how much more interesting fugues are if you simply relax and listen.  What you hear tends to be a fascinating dispersal of long notes amid running passages. The trajectory of the long notes is utterly compelling.

I recommend to people that they approach their music via the long notes, not via the themes or the melodies.  The long notes convey both harmony and rhythm, and sometimes (especially in Beethoven!) even melody.

Saturday, January 31, 2015

Body / Piano Playing : A Real Connection

One of my favorite students is an innovative scientist who has never been tempted to ignore the powerful drive to have music in her life.

Today she was working on the beginning of a Beethoven slow movement.  It is a privilege to work with someone whose sense of detail is so cultivated that she can appreciate the connection between this small step and that dynamic result.

It was a matter of overcoming anxiety about playing wrong notes: a familiar problem.

The hint very often lies in feeling the connection between the hand and the keyboard.  We tend to forget that the hand came first and approach the keyboard as a foreign object, whereas it is really the other way around.  The fifth is beautifully expressed by the five fingers in closed position.  Extending that reach ever so slightly to produce a sixth can be an utterly expressive gesture, in fact, an extension very like what a fine dancer executes to command our attention.

Treated mechanically the sixth is not expressive at all.  It was beautiful to hear what happened when notes stopped being notes and became actual physical gestures which, like fine choreography, conveyed real feeling.

Friday, January 30, 2015

Competing with Oneself

What am I doing when I get up to play for other people?

It is hard to shake the many years of feeling as if every performance is competitive, even when it is not.  But the possibility that I might be competing with myself did not occur to me until a pre-performance chat with a fellow pianist.

Even with maturity it does not get easier to go to the source and find what one needs to know and get the courage to go in pursuit of it.  There are so many factors pulling us down into the pre-judged, not-good-enough mode of much of our learning years.

This learned put-down keeps us from hearing in the here and now, that precious, fleeting moment when Mozart might reach us with a tone or tone relationship that we had never noticed before.

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Rules? Models? Competition?

A few years ago I had an interesting email exchange with a well-known music theorist who has taken an interest in disability.  Replying to his questioning why I was interested in it my answer was that disability has alerted us to the extent to which conformity distracts from real learning by reducing singular works by singular individuals to a set of rules and procedures.

What does it take to direct a person's attention to the source? To get a child to feel confident that music is an inter-personal communication, not something objectified, standardized?

It takes attentiveness to and support of the child's ear.

Sounds simple.  Takes time.

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Models or the Real Thing?

Already as a very young girl I had an awareness of "the real thing."  An interesting notion: That an unschooled child could have a notion of what that might be.

The plastic toy that looked like a sailboat but which, contrary to my excited expectations, sank was clearly not it.  The neighbor's spinet with no model attached either in print or in the person of a piano player was the real thing and has remained so for my entire life.

It was me and that sound with no intermediary.

When, then, specific sounds composed by someone who had lived 200 years earlier awoke in me a recognition that we were reacting to the same thing I knew it was real.

Lessons, classes, required recitals, had, for the most part nothing to do with it.  They conveyed rules, models, competition, categorical judgments--all beside the point.